“So good. We sent out a call for samples and ended up with a few varieties from six popular brands—Klondike, Chipwich, Nestlé Toll House, Trader Joe’s, Turkey Hill, and Coolhaus, which are all available in grocery stores. The classic Klondike chocolate and vanilla sandwiches? This was the least expensive of the boxes we bought ($4.99 for a box of six), which was surprising considering the fact that these sandwiches are organic. But in the case of the ice cream sandwich, simpler is better. Sarah Schmalbruch / INSIDER, The first thing that struck us about the Fat Boy ice cream sandwich — besides the brand's interesting name choice — was its shape. This Coolhaus ice cream sandwich is made with S’Mores cookie butter swirl ice cream, which is then sandwiched between graham toasted marshmallow chocolate chip cookies. A box of six cost a dollar less than Fat Boy ($6.49). “The perfect size, too. “Incredible. Score: 5.6 For that classic ice cream sandwich—you know, the kind served at school picnics and kids’ parties—turn to Nestlé. After laying out each respective sandwich in a line (cut into bite-sized pieces), our editors taste-tested every single one, noting the flavor and texture of the sandwiches, as well as how well the ice cream paired with its respective cookie counterpart. A slow cooker can can take your comfort food to the next level. Food & Wine is part of the Meredith Corporation Allrecipes Food Group. We found them to be rich and have good texture; however, in sandwich form, it ended up being too big for some of us to finish. Credit: Some enjoyed it and compared it to a classic “ice cream truck-style sandwich,” while others liked the cookie wafers, but weren’t as sure about the ice cream itself. Sarah Schmalbruch / INSIDER. But if you're looking for a bargain, 365 Everyday Value is your best bet; a box of 6 ice cream sandwiches for under $5 is a pretty good deal. “This tastes like Christmas,” one editor wrote. Toggle navigation Toggle search bar. This sandwich had the best ice cream — the richest and most flavorful. Sure, they’re at their peak in the summer, when Chipwiches are a standard poolside snack and kids clamor around ice cream trucks to grab their favorites. We taste-tested 50 store-bought flavors, from chocolate ice cream to caramel cookie crunch, in the GH Test Kitchen to pick the best ice creams for dessert. Nestle ice cream sandwich. Sarah Schmalbruch / INSIDER. The ice cream was flavorless, there was too much of it, and, on the whole, the sandwich tasted artificial. Food and Wine presents a new network of food pros delivering the most cookable recipes and delicious ideas online. Used to eat these too much in college,” an editor noted. Fans of York Peppermint Patties would definitely enjoy them. A list of the most popular scanned grocery products in the category of frozen dessert > ice cream sandwich. Account active Plus, Fat Boy was the most expensive of the three brands we sampled. By Joe Sevie r Keep scrolling to see which one we enjoyed the most. “Wowza! Overall, we found Fat Boy to have an artificial taste, making it not worth the $7.49 for a box of six. I love these—never had them before, but will be buying them!”. The generous amount of chocolate chips was a treat; the texture of the cookie was also praised. 365 Everyday Value ice cream sandwich. Our favorite part of this sandwich was the cookie, which paired well with the crunchy chocolate chips ringed around the ice cream. Honestly amazing, great tasting ice cream and perfect cookie to ice cream ratio,” one editor wrote. “Cookie is sweet, perfect ratio of chocolate chips in the coating,” one editor said. It had a strong chocolate flavor and the texture of a soft graham cracker. We tried breakfast sandwiches from 6 fast food chains — here's the only one you should buy. It was a close call between Nestle and 365 Everyday Value, but in the end, we chose Nestle as our winner. But the cookie was relatively tasteless, which took away from the sandwich's overall taste.